Throughout the trial, many questions about the story arose. The first thing I wondered about was Tom Robinson's arm. When he stands up in court, it says, "his left arm was fully twelve inches shorter than his right, and hung dead at his side" (186). If the injury was on the right side of Mayella's face and those injuries would have been caused by someone's left hand, how would Tom have hit her if he doesn't have a left hand? Also, Why is everyone still so convinced that it was Tom if this evidence points against it?
I do not believe Tom raped Mayella, so I wonder why their stories are so different. When Atticus is questioning her, he asks "Who beat you up? Tom Robinson or your father?" (187). Mayella does not answer this question and I wonder why she doesn't. I know that when I don't answer questions, it can be because I am afraid to say the answer and it is easier to just keep quiet. Was Mayella keeping quiet because telling everyone that her father beat her up would be too hard to admit?
No comments:
Post a Comment